Pour your milk into a stainless steel pan. Warm it to the edge of boiling. (By that, I mean, don’t let it come to a rolling boil – just to where it begins to bubble.) Shut the burner off, then let it cool down to where you can touch your finger to the top of it. It should sting a tiny bit, but not burn you. You don’t want it to kill the live cultures in the starter.
Once you can touch it like that, take your starter. It should be about 1/2 c. of yogurt per gallon. Make sure that the date is within range. Out of date does not work. You can use your own home-made after the first time.
So, when the milk is the right temp, whisk in the starter. (I like to set my starter on the counter to warm it up a little so it isn’t shocked so much by the warm milk.) If I want to stir in vanilla, I do so at this time.
Then, insulate your pan. I put mine in my crock pot, then put on the insulated cover. You can wrap it in towels, away from a draft, like in your oven.
Let it sit for 8 hours. Less than that by much, and it won’t be set. More than that, and it starts to turn sour.
It sometimes separates, but I either stir that in or use the whey for various other things (like soaking beans.)
If it really fails, big time, I just use it for smoothies.

This recipe is from my friend Holly! Please visit her at http://seekingfaithfulnessblog.blogspot.com/
SIDE NOTE: I normally don’t add my flavoring until after the yogurt is made.
Blessings, Mrs. Bumppo
